Well, let's start.
Your first work is probably your best one, bg looks like and fits the render(since the bg is basically blurred render). 8-8.5/10
I don't like your second work, the render is way too blurry and the background just doesn't look good. Also the text should not cover your render. 5.5/10
Your 3rd one ain't nothing too pleasant aswell. Again you abused the blur tool in a bad way, although it makes a nice eff around the render, the render itself is ruined. Also left side, which is about 30% of this siggy is simply black which kinda ruins what already doesn't look too good. 5/10
Your last one is your worse. Rubbish combination of random brushes, low quality render and totally out of place font makes it a disaster. It looks like colorful melt down cheese on the background. Again you overabused the blur tool.
It looks as you wrote the text with a marker. Out of place and makes bad worse. 2.5/10
You ain't bad for a beginner. Eventually you'll learn to critize your own works and realize what's wrong with them before even posting on the internet.
Try watching some tutorials on the web or ask people to teach you some tricks. I could teach you few basics when I'm free if ya' want.
What I can tell ya' now is to get new fonts, since a text actually matters lot in your signatures and a wrong one can literally destroy other aspects of your signature.
Also, don't blur the renders. It doesn't look good most of times.
Don't take my words as insult. We aren't insulting anyone on GWWD. We simply criticize.
It would be a lie if I gave your works a high scores. So better take it low now and then improve and get honest high scores.
Anyways, good luck with your gfx and hope to see more of your works in the future.
Last edited by Mizara on Sat May 22, 2010 9:19 am; edited 1 time in total